" /> The Old Prof: October 2003 Archives

« September 2003 | Main | November 2003 »

October 26, 2003

The Legend Goes On

How We Could All Write a Book About Anything Whether we knew anything about it or not. From a book about: Eleanor of Aquitaine, Or, How We could all write a book about anything. [maybe, perhaps, if, one might conjecture?.] Introduction The following phrases or words are gathered at random from page one through page fifty six where I finally saw no further reason to read. If one is interested, one may read or not read my excerpts for some time and stop when ones own patience runs thin as mine did on page 56. There are a further one hundred and sixty one pages of conjecture. And now, on to the meat of the book. Brace yourselves for "truths that burn like fire". If only so much information is now past recovery there is far more that only Eleanor herself could tell would Eleanor really have been the question is unanswerable one can imagine she may even at an early age end of p. 1 what they may suggest having attempted to sift fact from fiction truth was in any case infinitely malleable is it possible the matter is certainly worth considering for it is not inconceivable [now there's a truth] end of page 2 Chapter 1 there is no certainty as to the date it is most commonly thought doubtless she may even have end of p. 3 it has been claimed end of p. 4 We can imagine it seems end of p. 7 It seems it is more than likely end of p. 8 it does appear it is likely too end of p. 10 We can imagine her [apparantly so] end of p. 11 No doubt as end of p. 12 Eleanor must have sensed that end of p. 13 Chapter 2 One can imagine was likely does at least appear is it pure coincidence if was he also would she have thought or might she have we have no record of it would be surprising if but we're left to guess end of p. 15 It would be surprising if how far Eleanor participated... is impossible to say but there is reason to suppose that she would have end of p. 16 one is tempted... to ascribe to her probably it is... suggestive it has been suggested end of p. 17 The parallels... are striking. Do they amount to pure coincidence ? Or? it is even possible what ever the truth end of p. 19 he could not have shrugged off Eleanor's involvement... is largely a matter of speculation. She has been suspected of it is however impossible to say end of p. 20 It seems end of p. 21 Why should Eleanor have accompanied him.... Some chroniclers suggest and anyway so it may not have been although they may have it could of course be said perhaps in all likelihood if some end of p. 22 An intriguing, but unprovable, possibility is end of p. 23 Could not have failed to impress her there was room for graver suspicions some were to hint end of p. 24 One can imagine that seems to have no doubt we can only guess end of p. 25 Of Eleanor?s activities... we know nothing one must assume there would still have been much there was no reason for it is tempting to it might have end of p. 26 the work was probably perhaps it is a reasonable assumption one imagines end of p. 27 Could hardly have failed to would Eleanor herself have kept a straight face [can anyone?] she it seems who was no doubt perhaps if end of p. 28 If she knew was later to claim on the other hand he may have had one should be wary of imagining end of p. 30 others think whenever the truth we cannot know so whether end of p. 31 his new bride would certainly have one wonders if she might have end of p. 32 A rich subject for speculation might be thought we do not know exactly how it is likely to one proof of it has been suggested Matilda doubtless we may be sure that end of p. 34 Probably she was more likely to have perhaps end p. 37 But although there is nothing inherently improbable in this it cannot be proved end of p. 38 he must have a curious indirect indication end of p. 39 Eleanor would no doubt have a particular attraction would have been would she have wondered perhaps Eleanor may have presumably Eleanor's father was probably told seems to be there is some doubt as to but it is commonly believed that which is most likely to it is also problematic end of p. 40 Smoke without fire? Historical inaccuracies warn us on the other hand would not have been however may never have end p. 41 So on the likely assumption that we can be sure end of p. 42 one imagines her but she may have felt not that she would have been if she appears to have if we can believe though he speaks in general terms it is easy to visualize so she is unlikely to have probably quite the reverse in any case end of p. 43 We can only guess at probably perhaps even if reports... are to be discounted end p. 44 one can imagine the was it then with some regret that he seems to have been perhaps this is why how often in the Queens company we cannot say probably at Easter end of p. 46 Eleanor remain tactfully in England... nursing her own thoughts [And I?m astonished we are not told what those thoughts were] it is likely and been no doubt privy to but it is unlikely end p. 47 the exceptional severity of that winter would have done nothing to raise her spirits. Information... during this period is sparse [apparently] one senses one might think it is possible that presumably at end of p. 48 It is not difficult to grasp... but it is impossible to know... one may legitimately wonder how was left to imagine surely she must if so might the result not have been it would not be surprising if end of p. 49 Eleanor's part in it, if any, is largely a matter of guesswork [Its hard not to have favorites but this is good] she may not have felt one detects if we could observe did she connive with or did she secretly end of p. 51 to Becket may have been to some extent whenever her private feelings did this perhaps it may not be too fanciful to think of but we can never know end of p. 52 We know little of Eleanor's activities [either before or after reading all this] it is likely that the King would hardly have and if one wonders where must have been end p. 53 It must of been there she would have unlikely as the rumor is end of p. 54 May have had brief meetings in order perhaps to are largely conjecturural, but there is some evidence logic would seem to demand why then could this be the explanation, if we could know it, might not be so end of p. 55 One could invent a scenario a more dramatically appealing if equally speculative theory has been advanced. It assumes that.... end of p. 56 [and end of my patience]

October 25, 2003

evacuation is not mandatory

Fire in the sky “Evacuation is not mandatory at this time. We would actually prefer people to stay.” That is a line from the police scanner I am running right now. We have fires on the north and on the west of us and have had all day. Toward dusk the fire broke over the ridge and highlighted the hills. The sky was magnificent. The clouds were clouds of thick, deep smoke in every muted and gorgeous hue you didn’t know you had never seen before. They lay in ranks of color one before the other like someone had torn thick paper in a magnificent collage. The patterns were incredible. And now houses are endangered and one feels cadish for having loved the patterns and colors. Some sort of disassociation of the sensibilities must have occurred that allowed the enjoyment earlier. I wonder now at Robert E. Lee's statement on looking at the smoking battlefield. “It is well that war is so horrible, otherwise we should grow too fond of it.” I wonder if he really felt it to be horrible or whether he was just…more cautious of public opinion and less overtly revelatory than George Patton who is said to have said of war, while also looking at a smoldering battle field, ” …how I love it.” The sky was pretty.